Concrete floor sealer vs epoxy for a garage

A sealer protects the concrete you have. Epoxy gives you a new, bonded floor on top. Here is how the four kinds of sealer compare with epoxy on dust, oil, salt, tyres, slip, downtime and DIY, and when a garage needs sealing at all.

The short answer

A concrete sealer soaks into the slab or leaves a thin clear film. It stops dust and slows water, salt and stains, and it keeps the floor looking like concrete. An epoxy coating is a hard, bonded layer on top that takes oil, tools and tyres and gives you a finished, coloured floor. Seal a store or a lightly used garage. Coat a garage you park in or a workshop you work in. And if you might coat later, check the sealer first: some of them say on their data sheet that nothing can be painted over them.

Bare concrete in a garage does three annoying things. It dusts, so everything on the shelves goes grey. It soaks up oil, so every drip becomes a permanent mark. And it drinks in water and road salt off the car in winter. A sealer and an epoxy coating both deal with that, but in very different ways, and "sealer" covers four quite different products. Here is how each one behaves on a real garage or workshop floor, how long it keeps you off the floor, how much you need, and the one mistake that turns a cheap seal into an expensive problem later.

The quick comparison (scan this first)

What it doesFilm on top?Back in use at 20°CCoat over it later?
Silicate dustprooferReacts with the concrete to harden the surface and stop dustNo, it goes into the slabTwo coats 24 hours apart, then a hose-down after another 24One UK sheet says "Do not paint once treated"
Silane or siloxaneSoaks in and makes the slab shed water and saltNo, it lines the poresSecond coat after about 2 hours at 20°CWater beads on it, which is the sign epoxy will not stick
Acrylic sealerBinds, hardens and dustproofs, low sheenA thin oneParked vehicles after about 24 hoursOnly after it is ground off
Polyurethane floor sealClear gloss film, very hard wearing for its thicknessYes, about 60 microns a coatFoot 16 hours, heavy traffic 36, full cure 3 to 4 daysOnly after it is ground off
Epoxy coatingA coloured, bonded floor that takes oil, chemicals and vehiclesYes, a thick bonded buildCar back on after about 48 hours to 7 days, by productIt is the coating

Times are from UK manufacturers' data sheets at 20°C, and every one of them stretches in a cold garage. If you are weighing epoxy against a tin of floor paint rather than a sealer, that is a separate comparison, and our page on resin flooring vs garage floor paint covers it. The rest of this page explains each row.

What a concrete sealer is: four different products

Walk the sealer aisle at a builders' merchant and the tins all promise to "seal" concrete. Underneath, they are four different chemistries, and they do different jobs.

Silicate dustproofers and hardeners

These are the clear, watery liquids sold as "dustproofer and concrete hardener", based on sodium or lithium silicate. Sika describes its UK product as one that "reacts chemically with the lime content of concrete to form a surface that resists wear, efflorescence and surface degradation", and lists garages, utility rooms and driveways as uses. It dries clear, so the floor still looks like concrete, just harder and cleaner. You brush or spray it on at about 1 litre per 5 m², put a second coat on 24 hours later, then 24 hours after that hose the whole floor down to wash off whatever did not react.

It only works on cement-based surfaces, it will not save concrete that is already breaking up, and the slab has to be at least 28 days old. Repairs go in first.

Silane and siloxane water repellents

These soak into the pores and leave them water-repellent while still letting the slab breathe. Fosroc's Nitocote SN502, a silane-siloxane, is sold to cut water and salt absorption and is "chemically resistant to ice melting compounds, fuels, oils and atmospheric contaminants". That makes this family a good fit where the problem is wet tyres and winter road salt dripping off the car. It is sold to stop water and salt, not dust, so a powdery floor still wants a hardener. It can darken some surfaces, so try a patch first.

Acrylic sealers

An acrylic sealer binds the surface and leaves a thin, low-sheen layer. Watco's water-based one is "a micronised acrylic which penetrates deep into porous surfaces to bind, harden and seal", and it lists garages among its uses. It covers 40 to 50 m² per 5 litres per coat, is recoatable after 6 hours, and takes parked vehicles after 24 hours at 20°C. It needs at least 10°C, a dry slab, and laitance (the weak, powdery skin on top of the slab) taken off by mechanical abrasion first. Watco says not to use it on very smooth or power-floated concrete.

Polyurethane floor seals

A polyurethane (PU) seal is a clear gloss film rolled on in two or three thin coats, about 60 microns each, so all three together are still only a fraction of a millimetre. It is very hard wearing for its thickness and resists oils and petrol well. The data sheets are honest about its limit: it is "not recommended as a chemical resistant finish", and "floor seals can be readily damaged by impact and chemicals can then attack the concrete from underneath the seal". Drop a spanner hard enough to chip it, and the spill gets under it. Solvent-based PU seals also need a well-ventilated space while they go on.

What an epoxy coating does differently

Epoxy is a two-part resin mixed on site that cures into a hard plastic bonded to the slab. A trade epoxy goes down in two coats of about 0.25 kg per m² each, onto concrete that has been diamond ground or shot blasted. The KDR sheet calls for a surface "free of contaminants such as dirt, oil, grease, coatings and surface treatments", with a working damp proof membrane and residual moisture in the slab of no more than 75% relative humidity. Even Rust-Oleum's DIY garage epoxy is rated for "foot and vehicle traffic" and "resists chemicals and standing water", and it takes colour chips or an anti-slip additive.

The difference is not just thickness. A sealer protects the concrete you have. Epoxy replaces the surface you walk and drive on: a coloured, wipe-clean floor in a solid colour or a flake finish, with the concrete underneath no longer part of the picture. The price of that is prep and downtime. UK epoxy sheets put the car back on after about 48 hours to 7 days, and most epoxies want the air and the slab at 10 to 15°C or more while they cure. Our epoxy vs polyaspartic comparison has the faster option if a week off the floor is a problem.

The trap: sealing now can stop you coating later

This is the part that costs people money. Sika's dustproofer sheet lists, in plain words, "Do not paint once treated." Rust-Oleum's epoxy sheet says not to coat "concrete containing a curing compound", and it gives a test: drip a little water on the floor, and "if the water beads, a sealer is present and paint may not adhere properly." KDR's trade epoxy wants "previous surface treatments" ground off before it goes down.

Put those together and the rule is simple. If there is any chance you will want an epoxy floor in the next few years, do not silicate or siloxane the slab now to tide you over. A sealer that has soaked in has to be ground out before resin will bond, which is extra grinding on top of the normal prep for a resin floor.

The two-minute water test

Drip a few drops of water on the floor in three or four places. If it darkens the concrete and soaks in, the slab is open and unsealed. If it sits in beads, something is in or on the surface: an old sealer, a curing compound, or oil. That tells you two things at once: whether an old sealer is still working, and whether the floor needs grinding before anything else can go on it.

Dust, oil, salt and hot tyres

  • Dust. A silicate hardener or an acrylic sealer is the cheapest fix for a dusting slab. Sika says its hardener "leaves a residual surface to prevent further dusting". Epoxy stops it completely, because the concrete is no longer the surface.
  • Oil and fuel. A sealer slows a drip down so you have time to wipe it up. It does not make the floor oil-proof. A PU seal resists oil and petrol but chips under impact, and anything spilled then gets under it. Epoxy is the one rated for chemicals: KDR's sheet says "excellent general chemical resistance".
  • Water and road salt. This is where a silane or siloxane earns its place. It keeps salty slush from soaking into the slab without changing how the floor looks.
  • Hot tyres. A penetrating sealer leaves no film on top, so there is nothing for a warm tyre to pull up. The risk sits with thin films laid on unground concrete, which is the classic way floor paint fails. A properly bonded epoxy on a ground slab is a different thing, and our floor paint comparison explains why.

Slip: which one is slippery when wet?

HSE measures floor grip with a pendulum test. A Pendulum Test Value (PTV) of 36 or more is low slip potential, 25 to 35 moderate, and 24 or under high. HSE also points out that most slips happen on floors with something on them, such as water or grease, which is exactly what a garage floor has on it in winter.

A penetrating sealer leaves the concrete's own texture, so the grip barely changes. A clear gloss PU seal or a smooth gloss epoxy is a different surface, and smooth surfaces lose grip when wet: HSE rates a surface roughness below 10 microns as high slip potential in the wet. The fix on epoxy is aggregate. KDR's slip-resistant version is tested above 60 dry on the pendulum, and for heavier grip aggregate is scattered into the first coat while it is wet. Our anti-slip resin floors and the FAQ on whether resin is slippery when wet go further.

Parking on it and working on it? Get the floor coated

Tell us the size of the garage or workshop, what it takes day to day and whether anything has ever been put on the slab. We will check the concrete and price a ground, bonded epoxy floor in one fixed written quote.

How long each lasts, and when to redo it

No data sheet puts a number of years on a sealer, and the honest answer is that it lasts until it wears off where the tyres and feet go. The water test above is how you tell: when drops stop beading or the floor starts to dust again in the wheel tracks, it needs another coat. A PU seal is the easiest to refresh on top of itself, though the sheet says to abrade the old coat first if the 24-hour recoat window has passed. A silicate hardener is a one-way change to the surface rather than a layer, so you top it up only where it dusts again.

Epoxy is a much longer job to undo or redo, which is why it is laid once, onto a properly prepared slab. How long one lasts is in our FAQ on how long an epoxy floor lasts, and what refreshing a tired one involves is on recoating an epoxy floor.

Doing it yourself: how hard, and how much product

Sealing is a proper weekend DIY job. Clean the floor, degrease the oil patches, fix the cracks, then roll or spray. The hard part is the prep for the sealers that need laitance taken off, which means hiring a grinder. For an 18 m² single garage, the top of the 15-18m² size UK cost guides price against, the data sheet coverage rates work out roughly like this:

ProductCoatsRoughly how much for 18 m²
Silicate dustproofer (1 litre per 5 m²)2About 3.6 litres a coat, so two 5 litre cans
Acrylic sealer (40 to 50 m² per 5 litres)1 or 2About 2 litres a coat, so one 5 litre tin for two coats
PU floor seal (7 to 9 m² per kg)2 or 3About 2 to 2.6 kg a coat, 4 to 8 kg in all
DIY water-based epoxy (about 7 m² per litre)1About 2.6 litres
Trade epoxy (0.25 kg per m² per coat)2About 4.5 kg a coat, 9 kg in all

Porous, rough concrete drinks more, so buy for the top of the range. Epoxy is the harder DIY job by some way. Once it is mixed the clock is running: the DIY water-based kit gives 1 to 2 hours and Rust-Oleum advises two people, one cutting in the edges while the other rolls. Trade epoxies give 15 to 25 minutes. The prep is heavier too, and the slab must pass a moisture test: tape a sheet of plastic down for 24 hours and check for condensation underneath. Our step-by-step on how to epoxy a garage floor walks through it, and epoxy floor problems covers what goes wrong.

What it costs

Published UK rates put a laid thin coating at £30-£60 per m², a self-levelling epoxy at £40-£80 per m², and grinding or blasting the slab at £8-£20 per m² on top where it is priced separately. For a single garage of 15-18m², the published range is £700-£1,800, with a poured floor or a slab that needs heavy prep at the top. A DIY sealer is a tin, a roller and your weekend, with no labour in the price, which is its whole appeal. The fuller breakdown is in our garage floor cost page.

Do you need to seal a garage floor at all?

No. It is a choice, not a requirement, and a bare slab that is not dusting or staining can be left alone. Seal it when the bare slab is causing you a problem:

  • it dusts, and everything stored in there turns grey;
  • you bring a wet, salty car in over winter;
  • you want oil drips to wipe up rather than soak in;
  • it is a store or utility space where looks do not matter much.

If you park on it every day, work on it, or want it to look like a finished room, a sealer is a holding measure and a coating is the answer. In that case leave the slab bare until it is coated, so there is nothing extra to grind out. For a workshop that takes dropped tools and spilled fluids, our workshop resin flooring page shows what that floor looks like, and for polished bare concrete as a third route, see resin flooring vs polished concrete.

Already sealed it and now want epoxy?

Tell us what went on the slab and roughly when. Grinding the slab back is part of every floor we lay, and that is where old sealers and curing compounds come off. The quote covers the whole job, from the slab you have to a finished garage.

About this page

Who wrote this

The Obsidian Resin team wrote this comparison of concrete sealers and epoxy. We grind, repair and coat garage and workshop floors anywhere in Great Britain, and an old sealer on the slab is one more thing that has to come off before any resin goes down.

Where the facts come from

Every figure here is from a UK manufacturer's data sheet (Sika, Watco, Fosroc, Resdev, Virtus Resins, Rust-Oleum and KDR Resin Systems), HSE's guidance on assessing the slip resistance of flooring, or published UK cost ranges.

Our honest position

We lay epoxy, so we have a commercial interest in coated floors. A sealer is still the right call for plenty of garages, and we would rather you sealed a store room yourself than paid for a floor it does not need.

Frequently asked questions

Do you need to seal a garage floor?
No, it is not required. Seal it if the bare concrete dusts, soaks up oil, or takes in water and road salt off the car. If you plan to put epoxy down later, leave it bare, because most sealers have to be ground out before a coating will bond.
Is a concrete sealer or epoxy better for a garage floor?
A sealer is better for a store or lightly used garage where you only want to stop dust and stains. Epoxy is better for a garage you park in or a workshop you work in, because it takes oil, chemicals, impact and vehicles and gives a finished floor.
Can you put epoxy over a sealed concrete floor?
Not as it is. Epoxy data sheets want sealers, curing compounds and other surface treatments ground or blasted off first, and one UK silicate dustproofer says on its sheet not to paint once treated. The slab has to be ground back to open concrete.
How do I know if my garage floor has been sealed?
Drip some water on it in a few places. If it darkens the concrete and soaks in, the slab is unsealed. If it beads on the surface, there is a sealer, curing compound or oil in it, and that has to come off before any coating goes on.
Will a sealer stop hot tyre marks?
A penetrating sealer leaves no film for a hot tyre to lift, so peeling is not the problem. Thin films on unground concrete are where hot tyre pickup happens. A bonded epoxy on a ground slab is the coating built for parked cars.
Does sealing stop concrete dust?
Yes. A silicate hardener or an acrylic sealer is made for exactly that. A silane or siloxane is sold to stop water and salt rather than dust, so a powdery floor wants a hardener.
How often does a garage floor sealer need redoing?
There is no fixed interval. Redo it when water stops beading in the wheel tracks or the floor starts to dust again. A PU seal can be recoated on top once the old coat is abraded.
How much does an epoxy garage floor cost?
Published UK rates put a self-levelling epoxy at £40-£80 per m² and a single garage of 15-18m² at £700-£1,800. See our garage floor cost page for the full breakdown.
What is the difference between epoxy flooring and concrete paint?
Paint is a thin film that often goes onto an unground slab and peels. Epoxy flooring is a thick build bonded to ground concrete. Our resin flooring vs floor paint page covers it in full.

Read enough? Send us the space and your postcode, and get the written figure for your own floor or driveway.