Resin driveway vs tarmac

Tarmac is cheaper; resin-bound looks better and drains through on the right base. How the two compare on cost, colour, drainage, hot-weather wear and longevity, and which suits your driveway.

The short answer

Tarmac is the cheaper option and it is hard to beat on a big, plain, hard-wearing drive, but it is black unless you pay for a coloured binder, standard tarmac is impermeable, and its bitumen softens in hot weather, when turning wheels can scuff it. Resin-bound costs more but gives a smooth, decorative surface in a wide colour range that drains through on the right base, with no bitumen in it to soften. If budget is the deciding factor, tarmac wins; if you want the look, drainage and finish, resin-bound does.

Tarmac and resin are often the shortlist when you want a smooth driveway rather than block paving or gravel. They can look similar from a distance, but they are very different surfaces underneath, and the right choice usually comes down to budget against looks and drainage. Here is how a resin-bound driveway compares with tarmac, including where tarmac is the sensible call. If block paving is also in the mix, see our resin driveway vs block paving guide.

The quick comparison (scan this first)

Resin-bound drivewayTarmac
Colour and finishWide range of aggregate colours, decorativeBlack, or red with a coloured binder at extra cost
Permeable (drains through)Yes, on a permeable baseStandard tarmac no; porous asphalt is a specialist option
Hot weatherBound with polyurethane, not bitumenBitumen softens in high temperatures
Turning on the spotMakers warn against turning wheels while stationaryScuffs when soft in hot weather
Oil and fuelClean spills off fast with detergentPetrol, diesel and light oils dissolve the binder
Installed cost, full build£65-£115 per m²£40-£80 per m²
Lifespan (UK guides)15 to 25 years15 to 25 years, with upkeep every few years
Kerb appealPremium, decorativePlain, utilitarian

In short, tarmac wins on price and resin wins on looks and drainage. Here is what sits behind each of those differences.

Cost: tarmac's real advantage

There is no getting around it: tarmac is usually the cheaper surface to lay, and Rated People calls it cost-effective for large driveways. On a like-for-like full build, dig-out and sub-base included, UK cost guides put tarmac at £40-£80 per m² and a new resin-bound drive at £65-£115 per m². If the priority is covering a big drive with a sound, hard-wearing surface for the lowest outlay, tarmac is genuinely hard to beat and we will not pretend otherwise. What resin buys for the extra is the finish, the colour choice and the permeability, so the question is whether those are worth it to you. And if your tarmac is sound already, resin can go over it at £40-£70 per m². Within those ranges the price depends on area, base and access, as we set out in our cost guide.

Looks and colour

Side-by-side comparison of a warm coloured resin-bound driveway next to plain black tarmac
Tarmac comes in one colour; resin-bound comes from a wide range of natural aggregate blends.

This is the clearest everyday difference. Tarmac is black; it can be coloured with a coloured binder, but Pavingexpert notes red tarmac can cost more than block paving, and that coloured macadam may not be the same colour a year after laying. Resin-bound comes in a wide range of natural aggregate blends, from pale golds to greys and dark browns, so it can be matched to the house and the frontage. For many people the decorative finish is the whole reason they choose resin over a cheaper tarmac drive.

Permeability and drainage rules

Resin-bound on a permeable base lets rain drain straight through it into the ground rather than sheeting off into the road or a gully, and in England a permeable driveway of any size needs no planning permission. Standard tarmac is impermeable; the government guidance lists asphalt among the conventional impermeable surfaces, and porous asphalt is a separate product it says should be laid by a specialist. So on a new standard tarmac drive over five square metres of front garden you have to plan where the run-off goes, whether that is a lawn, a border or a rain garden, or apply for permission. We explain the rules in our guide to planning permission for a resin driveway.

Hot weather and turning

Tarmac is bitumen-bound, and bitumen softens in high temperatures, more so on old, badly laid or heavily used tarmac in direct sun. Soft patches, tyre marks and scuffing are the warning signs, and turning the wheels while stationary or leaving a heavy vehicle in one spot makes it worse. Resin-bound is bound with polyurethane, not bitumen, but it has its own rule: Vuba says tyres must not be turned on it while the car is stationary or crawling.

Deciding between resin and tarmac?

Tell us the drive's rough size and its current surface. We will give you a steer on whether resin is worth it over tarmac for your drive, and a quote at a fixed price.

Wear, scuffing and softening

Both are hard-wearing, but they wear differently. Tarmac is bound with bitumen, which softens in a hot spell and can scuff where wheels turn, and it has one weakness worth knowing about: Pavingexpert says spillages of light oils, petrol and diesel dissolve the binder, and the only remedy is to cut out the contaminated patch and fill it with new material. On resin-bound, oil should come off as soon as possible; DALTEX's method is a neat detergent left for ten minutes, then a wash. Both need a proper edge: concrete-bedded edge restraints are essential for tarmac, and every free edge of a resin drive needs one too.

Longevity and repairs

Laid well on a sound base, both last many years, and the UK guides put them in the same range: 15 to 25 years for tarmac (less.co.uk) and for resin-bound. Tarmac asks for more along the way: Rated People says it needs maintenance every few years, with more serious repair work every 15 to 20, and Pavingexpert says it cannot be invisibly repaired, so a patch will be obvious. Resin patches show too, but day to day a resin-bound drive needs little more than the occasional wash, as we cover in how long a resin driveway lasts. As with any driveway, the base and the workmanship matter more than the surface for how long it stays good.

So which should you choose?

Choose tarmac when:

Choose a resin-bound driveway when:

  • You want a decorative finish and a choice of colour to suit the house.
  • Rainwater should drain through the drive, not pool on it or run into the road.
  • You want a surface with no bitumen to soften in a heatwave.

About this guide

Who wrote this

The Obsidian Resin team wrote this resin and tarmac comparison. We lay resin-bound driveways anywhere in Great Britain, and tarmac is the surface resin is most often weighed against on price, so this guide puts the two side by side line by line.

Our honest position

Tarmac is not something we sell, so our bias runs towards resin. Even so, if budget is tight and you just need a large, plain, durable drive, tarmac is often the sensible call. Where the look, the colour and the drainage matter to you, that is where resin earns its extra cost.

Frequently asked questions

Is a resin driveway better than tarmac?
It depends what you value. Resin-bound wins on looks, colour choice, drainage and having no bitumen to soften in the heat. Tarmac wins on upfront cost, especially over a large area. UK guides give both 15 to 25 years. Neither is simply better; they suit different priorities.
Is resin more expensive than tarmac?
Usually, yes. On a full build UK cost guides put tarmac at £40-£80 per m² and a new resin-bound drive at £65-£115 per m². What you get for the extra is the finish, the colour range and the permeability. Over sound existing tarmac, resin goes on at £40-£70 per m².
Does resin or tarmac drain better?
Resin-bound on a permeable base lets water drain straight through it, which makes it easier to meet front-garden drainage rules. Standard tarmac is impermeable, so over five square metres of front garden in England the run-off has to go to a lawn, border or rain garden, or the drive needs permission.
Does tarmac soften in hot weather?
It can. Tarmac is bitumen-bound, and bitumen softens in high temperatures, especially on old, badly laid or heavily used tarmac in direct sun. Soft patches, tyre marks and scuffing are the signs. Resin-bound has no bitumen in it.
Can you lay resin over an existing tarmac driveway?
Often, yes. SureSet calls asphalt the ideal base and lays straight onto existing tarmac, provided it sits on an adequate sub-base. It must be sound and free of cracks, and laid over old tarmac it needs a soakaway or drainage route for the water. If it is cracked, soft or moving, it needs sorting or replacing first. We check the existing surface before advising.

Read enough? Send us the space and your postcode, and get the written figure for your own floor or driveway.